Investors who buy stocks now in anticipation of the announcement of President Donald Trump's tax plan are making a big mistake, say some market strategists.
Two weeks ago, Trump said that he would unveil a "phenomenal" tax plan in the next few weeks, which drew the attention of markets despite the lack of further details. More generally, the rise in stocks since Trump's election has partially been pinned on his announced plan to lower the federal corporate tax rate from 35 percent to 15 percent.
The problem, as Cowen & Co. head of equity sales trading David Seaburg put it, is that "we're pricing in and paying for a lot here" due to investors' "wickedly high expectations for just the tone of Trump's voice."
As a result, "I think that we've just boxed ourselves into a corner here," Seaburg said Friday on CNBC's "Trading Nation."
Doing a little back-of-the-envelope math, Seaburg said that about $1.30 is added to total annual S&P 500 earnings for every percentage point that taxes are cut. Even if the tax rate falls as low as 25 percent, which would be a 10 percent drop, then only $13 would be added to S&P earnings, bringing total 2017 earnings up to about $145.
"Given a realistic multiple of 17, we have a little more upside, or we're right around that level in the S&P right now … so I wouldn't be chasing the tape," Seaburg said.
According to the trader, expectations around the tax plan announcement have become so heightened that "I think the market comes in when the announcement's made," making the long-awaited tax plan unveiling "a sell-the-news event".
Max Wolff, market strategist with 55 Capital, is even more pessimistic.
"I think there's a lot of upside in the market that doesn't make much sense," he said Friday on "Trading Nation." "When you have a fantasy, you don't worry about the thorns on the rose, because there aren't any."
Indeed, the tax cut plan is predicated on a tax on imported goods, which would hurt corporate earnings, and potentially have negative ramifications on U.S. trade.
However, there appears to be much disagreement between the White House and the Republican-controlled Congress on the plan. On Monday, the AP reported that when it comes to tax policy, "Republicans have a potentially more vexing impasse" than on the also-fraught issue of an Affordable Care Act rollback.
Read more:
25 Canada Square, Level 33, office 50, Canary Wharf London, E14 5LQ +44 20 3608 6256
World Financial Markets - 0700 17 600 Varchev Exchange - 0700 115 44
Varchev Finance Ltd is registered in the FCA (FINANCIAL CONDUCT AUTHORITY) with a passport in the United Kingdom: FCA, United Kingdom - registration number: 494 045, which allows provision of financial services in the United Kingdom.
Varchev Finance Ltd strictly comply with the statutes of the European directive MiFID (Markets in Financial Instruments). targeting increased efficiency, transparency and uniformity of financial instruments.
Varchev Finance Ltd is authorized and regulated by the Financial Supervision Commission - Sofia, Bulgaria: License number RG-03-02-05 / 15.03.2006
The information on this site is not intended for distribution or use by any person in any country or jurisdiction where such distribution or use would be contrary to local law or regulation.
Disclaimer:
CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. 63,41% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work, and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.